Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Printable Version +- phyphox Forums (https://phyphox.org/forums) +-- Forum: Discussion (https://phyphox.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Teaching and worksheets (https://phyphox.org/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Three phyphoxphones and superposition (/showthread.php?tid=1441) Pages:
1
2
|
Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Erik Josefsson - 10-04-2021 Hello! If two phyphoxphones at some distance from each other is set to generate a 1000 Hz sound wave (it's uncomfortable but not dangerous I think) then you should get interference/superposition at the same distance (0.34 m) as the local speed of sound (340 m/s). Is there a way to use a third phyphoxphone to manually find two or three of these maxima/minima? Exact measurement not needed, but a distance that students could confirm looks like about 30 cm would be great. Anyone tried to do it with "Audio Amplitude"? I hope it is possible to do with less gear than anno dazumal (see attached png)! Best regards. //Erik RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Jens Noriʇzsɔɥ - 10-04-2021 Dear Eric, there is an alternative with just one smartphone and earbuds suggested by the NPL, https://www.npl.co.uk/measurement-at-home/measuring-sound-using-toilet-rolls, and utilised by Physics in Advent on December 3, 2020, see https://youtu.be/wUAFem8eEKI and https://youtu.be/-8MO0Uacn5w Would this work for you? Best regards, Jens RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - solid - 10-04-2021 Hello Thank you for the references, Jens . I tried the toilet paper NPL experiment and I found it not very precise.. I got the wavelength 10 cm and the sound speed 400 m/s for the frequency of 4 kHz. Then I took one smartphone with phyphox sound generator at 4 kHz. I put its headphones 50 cm apart and took another smartphone with audio amplitude of phyphox and moved it slowly at a distance of 1 m over about 1 m. I tried to keep a constant speed of the motion. The result is here, could be better... Probably some things around including me interfere also. Best Mikhail RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Erik Josefsson - 10-05-2021 (10-04-2021, 09:43 AM)Jens Noritzsch Wrote: Dear Eric, That's a very nice setup! Thank you!! //Erik (10-04-2021, 05:43 PM)solid Wrote: Hello Well, one pair of headphones is actually two speakers, so we did more or less the same experiment :-) I was also trying to move the phyphoxphone/Audio Amplitude with constant speed, but your result is much better than mine! Thank you solid. //Erik Further to solid's response in this thread, has anyone seen device-specific calibration data for the Audio Amplitude experiment? My Galaxy III has a "Reference SPL" default setting 60 dB (not sure what the "offset" below does?), but maybe that's a default value set for all phones? Anyway, I will try again tomorrow with a larger tube than stacked toilet paper rolls. Turns out a transparent plastic curtain box from IKEA (FRIDANS) works perfectly as running tracks for their toy cars (LILLABO). Maybe I can pull a phyphoxphone on a string through it and get the Audio Amplitude to clearly detect sound wave interference peaks. //Erik RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - solid - 10-05-2021 Two phones maybe are not correlated well as two headphones of the same phone and the interference will be absent. . . By the way I did not use the toilet rolles, I used a tube. The tube length is limited by the distance between the headphones. RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Erik Josefsson - 10-05-2021 (10-05-2021, 02:52 AM)solid Wrote: Two phones maybe are not correlated well as two headphones of the same phone and the interference will be absent. . . Two phones on 440 Hz sounds perfectly in tune to me. If the frequency would differ the slightest I think you would hear it, no? If you listen to 440 Hz from one and 441 Hz from the other you clearly hear a 1 Hz "pulse" (or "beat") from the interference. But volumes could differ of course! RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - solid - 10-05-2021 Hi Erik, I realized some measurements of the classical interference of (sound) waves from two "point" sources (headphones) from a smartphone using "Tone generator" of phyphox. In order to have a stronger sound I have added a small HiFi headphone amplifier as you can see on the given photo. The result of the interference measurements by a second smartphone with "Audio amplitude" of phyphox is not so bad. It could be better but somebody from a nearby laboratory was not too much happy hearing (reasonably) amplified 4000 Hz. For comparison I have calculated the expected interference pattern for exactly the same parameters:
Additionally a small modification of the "Audio amplitude" was done to see the sound intensity in the direct scale (also attached here). Unfortunately, I had to keep only French and German translations because somewhere in many others an error existed and I could not find it. Enjoy Mikhail RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Jens Noriʇzsɔɥ - 10-05-2021 (10-05-2021, 12:03 AM)Erik Josefsson Wrote: Further to solid's response in this thread, has anyone seen device-specific calibration data for the Audio Amplitude experiment? My Galaxy III has a "Reference SPL" default setting 60 dB (not sure what the "offset" below does?), but maybe that's a default value set for all phones? The calibration tab could be used for a rather vague calibration of the audio amplitude, either by a reference sound of known SPL or by remembering a previously measured offset. Sebastian has tried to explain the limitations in the FAQ tab. This gets particularly difficult now that we know about hardware variations in a device's lifetime, see https://phyphox.org/sensordb/ (Samsung Galaxy III could be any of the four –err, at least six different– GT-I930… or a SGH-I747M, tbc?). RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Erik Josefsson - 10-08-2021 (10-05-2021, 10:17 PM)Jens Noritzsch Wrote:(10-05-2021, 12:03 AM)Erik Josefsson Wrote: Further to solid's response in this thread, has anyone seen device-specific calibration data for the Audio Amplitude experiment? My Galaxy III has a "Reference SPL" default setting 60 dB (not sure what the "offset" below does?), but maybe that's a default value set for all phones? Thank you Jens, this brings me back to my "old phones" question since I just broke all the screens on all my Galaxy III phones. I see 52 Galaxy S5 (SM-G900F) in the sensor db and that DivestOS works on that model: https://divestos.org/index.php?page=faq Would you buy five of those for student's experimenting? Or would you prefer any other model? Best regards. //Erik (10-05-2021, 08:06 PM)solid Wrote: Hi Erik, That's really beautiful! Hey, wouldn't it be possible to compare "distance between minima" in time from the "Audio Amplitude" graph with actual location in space of the phyphoxphone if you'd have a magnet ruler? (I'm trying to figure out other uses of the magnet rulers I made for determining g since resolution at dropping speed wasn't good enough) Best regards. //Erik RE: Three phyphoxphones and superposition - Jens Noriʇzsɔɥ - 10-08-2021 Dear Erik, we do not have that much experience with the plethora of smartphones out there. I cannot perhaps read more information from our sensor database than you. From what I can see, it does look quite ok sensor wise, all “relevant“ on board including a barometer, which is great. I cannot judge their performance in smoothly running phyphox… Have a nice weekend. |