This forum uses cookies
This forum makes use of cookies to store your login information if you are registered, and your last visit if you are not. Cookies are small text documents stored on your computer; the cookies set by this forum can only be used on this website and pose no security risk. Cookies on this forum also track the specific topics you have read and when you last read them. Please confirm whether you accept or reject these cookies being set.

A cookie will be stored in your browser regardless of choice to prevent you being asked this question again. You will be able to change your cookie settings at any time using the link in the footer.

Collaborative experiment: Magnetic inclination and declination.
#1
I have tasked students with finding the magnetic inclination and declination as a project at my university. The students are not allowed to use any compasses or compass apps, as these are corrected for this effect. I hoped that someone would use the sun as a way to find the directions, the sun being in the local south around noon. Not many did that.
However, the problem may be rephrased so that you use the sun and find the inclination and declination, as you need the time and the sun's position in the sky, similar to the Suntrace project using phyphox. 
So, using a straw or the shadow, and align the phone with the sun, then send the position and time(UTC) to a server together with the readout of the magnetometer and it will be possible to calculate the inclination/declination, from the sun's position in the sky (calculated), post it on the server and send the result to the user in phyphox. In this way, it will be possible to build a map of variations and give users local values.

On paper, this seems doable, but I might have missed some issues. Is this possible, and is it worth doing, and who would be interested in collaborating?

There exists a project mapping the horizontal and vertical magnetic components (https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/crowd...netic-data), but as far as I know, nothing on the inclination and declination.
Reply
#2
[I had to check for alternatives to finding north (south)]

I like the simplicity of your approach with the sun. “Technical” solutions could be using GPS (the heading while moving is relative to “True North”, however, some speed is required for sufficient accuracy). Smartphones could also give you “True North”, this might utilise declination maps, though, so it's likely not something wanted.

At the moment, the angle “Direct α” in the “attitude” experiment, https://phyphox.org/wiki/index.php/Attitude_sensor, is relative to magnetic North. We are currently checking if we could provide the means in phyphox to obtain “True North” instead.

I agree that it looks doable and it looks like a nice network/crowd experiment. You certainly need to give some instructions on where –or where not– to measure the magnetic field. Typical school and university tables, for instance, have an iron construction underneath the table top that puts the magnetometer off. There is also the internal calibration of the raw data magnetometer, so overall accuracy is something that should be considered…

I'll check in our next group meeting what others think about your idea.
Reply
#3
One of my intentions is to make pupils aware of how we once used the sun for navigation. Thus, the project focuses on determining the magnetic inclination and declination and on how to use the sun for navigation. This way, it is possible to include other subjects in a school project.

I am on a sabbatical in Uppsala right now, and Anders Celsius (with the temperature scale), who was a professor in astronomy there, did measurements of the magnetic inclination and declination and whether it was influenced by auroras. They built a special house for that purpose without any metal.
Reply
#4
A few (late) comments on your idea…

Our experience from the sun trace network experiment is that we received quite a number of results that were obviously wrong. Our instructions apparently have not been clear enough so that people position their smartphone correctly. We threw those away – or we would not have had any result.

We are wondering if you can achieve an appropriate accuracy with both finding north and even the orientation of the magnetic field. As already written, there are some external factors that could affect the local direction of the magnetic field. Moreover, the firmware of the smartphone itself needs to compensate for internal magnetic fields (compare the “standard” readings with the raw sensor data, a switch is in the three dots menu).

(there has been a post in the “Bugs” forum: could you resolve it? The iOS parser is more strict compared to that on Android. The editor should always output correct code, though.
Reply
#5
The main goal is not the result in itself but rather to make pupils/students/others aware of how we used to navigate, in addition to the fact that we have a magnetic inclination and that it changes. The procedure and showing what you can do with "simple" means are important ways to increase interest.
I am aware of the problems with systematic errors, but that is in itself an opportunity for discussing uncertainties in measurements. I let my students find the local inclination and declination using phyphox, and the results have a substantial spread so the discussion on why is interesting.

I did a quick test on finding the altitude and hour angle from the time and the position of the smartphone while aligning it to the sun, both with the method described in the sun trace experiment, and by fastening a drinking straw on the side of the smartphone. With this, I came within 6 degrees using the sun trace method and 3 degrees using the straw. So, finding the true north could be done.

NOAA has the app CrowdMag, https://www.ncei.noaa.gov/products/crowd...netic-data, which is used to collect data for finding magnetic anomalies, but it uses the World Magnetic Model to get the inclination. So, an experiment where one can get some indication, although uncertain, is interesting. At least we will work on it as a school open science project for next year's European Researchers' Night.

I finally resolved the problem, there was an extra <space> I didn't spot until I tried an online XML validator. So the project to collect SPL and frequency spectra will be implemented, with the use of a silent room calibration of the SPL at 40 dB. I will translate it into English and make it available as soon as I find some time.
Reply
#6
Sounds reasonable. We are looking forward for these. Smile

(The extra <space> is not editor related, is it? Is it something that we should document?)
Reply


Forum Jump: